4. Mississippi Master Plan for Education Technology
4.1 Curriculum Improvement and Technology Intergration Strategies/Changing
Nature of Curriculm
4.2 Education Technology System Design
4.3 Education Accountability and Reporting System Design
4.4 Learning Enviroments and Facilities Planning
4.5 Distance Learning
Sections 4.6 - 4.10
Back to Table of Contents
Effective activities most frequently are guided by a structure that
provides clear direction to all personnel involved. When vagueness or ambiguity
creeps in, the possibility for failure increases immensely. The teams of
people who have worked diligently to craft this Mississippi Master Plan
for Education Technology have striven to detail a strong framework in which
all school districts in Mississippi, regardless of demographic composition,
can function well and prosper, enhanced by instructional technologies. The
Master Plan is intended to serve as a tool of leadership -- one which will
encourage all affected entities to unite their efforts and pool their talents
so the instruction that is provided to all Mississippi citizens will function
at an optimum level.
This section of the Master Plan provides information concerning:
- curriculum improvement and technology integration strategies/changing
nature of curriculum
- education technology system design
- education accountability and reporting system design
- learning environments and facility planning
- distance learning
- professional development plans (for preservice and in-service teachers,
as well as administrators)
- education technology policy and procedures
- technology standards and procurement strategies
- roles and responsibilities of agencies and individuals, staffing positions,
and organizational structures of related agencies
- program monitoring and evaluation plan for the overall technology
planning process
In keeping with the intent of Senate Bill 3350 (specifically, Sections 18-41,
commonly referred to as the Technology Enhancement Act), this section addresses
the full instructional gamut. Strategies are given to meet existing needs
and to deploy an energetic plan for cultivating a robust future with technology-enhanced
learning. Plenty of room is left, though, for individual creativity and
sensible option exploration by school districts. Close coordination among
school districts, higher education entities, state agencies, and other support
organizations will be essential for clear success to be achieved.
4.1 Curriculum Improvement and Technology Integration
Strategies/Changing Nature of Curriculum
Leadership within the state envisions Mississippi classrooms where using
technology is as natural to students and teachers as using textbooks and
chalk. Technology should be integrated seamlessly throughout the curriculum.
Technology is neither an end in itself nor an add-on. It is a tool for improving
and, ultimately, transforming teaching and learning environments to provide
exciting and enriching 21st Century learning experiences.
As schools move into the 21st Century, Mississippi educators must challenge
all students to gain the appropriate knowledge, skills, and work ethics
necessary to function in an information-rich society and to adjust to the
ever-changing world of technology.
Communities throughout the United States are recognizing the need to rethink
curriculum offerings and the delivery of instruction. What has been appropriate
for the past 100 years no longer provides lucrative employment for today's
students. Defined as the "Communication Age", the approaching
century demands that students develop new roles in learning, living, and
working. In order to prepare students to become responsible citizens, workers,
learners, community members, and family members, schools need to go beyond
the traditional rote method of teaching reading, writing, and arithmetic
skills. In addition to teaching basic skills, schools are now challenged
to help all learners, teachers, and students alike to:
- think critically and to analyze information using technology
- communicate effectively through a variety of appropriate technological
media
- master skills required to interact with technology and to manage constant
change
- become discriminating users of appropriate sources of information
- become managers of and active participants in their own learning.
4.1.1 Existing Conditions
We have to challenge the notion that our math curriculum can continue
to consist of eight years of 15th Century arithmetic, followed by one year
of 17th Century algebra, followed by one year of 3rd Century B.C. geometry.
- Lamar Alexander, Former U.S. Secretary of Education
Just as
technology is reshaping other institutions, it has the potential to reshape
education, ending the disjunction between school and society. Technology
offers new ways of learning, of teaching, and of operating the school environment.
It provides new ways for everyone involved to be openly accountable to parents,
to communities, to administration, and to the student.
- The needs analysis conducted by the CELT team found that:
- Even though Mississippi school districts have academic curriculum
frameworks/structures in place, in most cases technology has not been integrated
into these curriculum-guiding documents.
- There is little systematic integration of technology into curriculum
although 70% of those surveyed viewed this as a top priority need.
- Districts do not have sufficient technology resources to begin the
process of curriculum and technology integration at all instructional levels
and across all disciplines.
- Teachers have not been trained sufficiently in the integration of
technology into the curriculum.
- Technology use is primarily limited to Title I computer labs and reading/writing
labs at the elementary level with few instances of the integration of technologies
past the basic reading and math instruction.
- There is limited use of adaptive and assistive technology devices
in special education settings.
4.1.2 Mississippi's Changing Instructional Landscape
Kids retain five percent of what they hear and ten percent of
what they read, but eighty percent of what they do and ninety percent of
what they teach.
- Robert Ballard, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution
What
began as a potential means of raising student achievement has evolved into
an intense effort to reconceptualize the learning process in light of 21st
Century needs. This effort has been accomplished by an increasing understanding
of the powerful roles that technology-based tools may play in facilitating
this process. There are currently several efforts underway to integrate
technology into the learning environment in Mississippi.
In Mississippi's new math curriculum structure, based on NCTM standards,
technology integration is stressed. This is continued in the development
of future state curriculum frameworks. Arts, English/reading, language arts,
and business/technical curriculums will be developed by April, 1996. These
new curriculums will emphasize skills that are valued in today's workforce,
including critical thinking, teamwork, compromise, and communications.
Through Mississippi's new assessment system, students are required to use
graphing calculators in the algebra section of the test. There has been
extensive teacher training done in this area by the Mississippi Department
of Education Office of Academic Education via the Community College Network.
The Mississippi Department of Education Office of Special Education (OSE)
has implemented an aggressive educational and evaluative campaign in the
area of assistive technology. In the fall of 1995, OSE will open an evaluation
center for assistive technology. This will be a state-of-the-art center
with assistive technology devices addressing such needs as positioning,
wheelchairs, computer applications (over $10,000 in computer software),
and speech augmentation. This center will be staffed with an occupational
therapist, physical therapist, and speech pathologist. The responsibilities
include evaluating children and making recommendations regarding the most
suitable assistive technology. Center staff will also be responsible for
teaching educators and families the appropriate use of these techniques
and resources.
To assist in training teachers, OSE is participating in a dissemination
grant from the University of New Mexico for the next three years. This project
provides thirty-two semester course hours in assistive technology delivered
by distance learning to ten sites in Mississippi. Also included in the coursework
resources are CD-ROMs, videotapes, e-mail, and use of the Internet to talk
with participants in the eight other states. The Office of Leadership & Professional Development
is working with the staff of OSE to develop this teacher training.
The Mississippi Department of Education, Office of Leadership & Professional Development,
is currently developing a training model to help teachers to integrate technology
into the curriculum. Teachers become guides or mentors who help students
navigate through the information made available by technology and interactive
communication. Both the teacher and technology become tools that students
draw upon to advance their own learning.
Writing-to-Read, a program of learning developed by IBM to teach kindergarten
and first graders to read, is currently in place in 162 schools across Mississippi.
Through this program, kindergarten and first-grade students are introduced
to keyboarding skills, begin developing writing and reading skills, and
strengthen listening and comprehension skills. Other educational activities
(both in class and at home) are coordinated with the classroom.
Mississippi Fibernet 2000 is a public/private partnership providing distance
education for students and enrichment, and inservice programs for teachers,
via an interactive compressed video and data network. Participating students
and teachers at remote locations can see and hear each other as well as
communicate via the wide-area computer network at all times. This network
was the first of its kind in the nation. It is designed to expand learning
opportunities in small, isolated, and rural school districts. Without leaving
their schools, students can attend classes in creative writing, foreign
languages, communications, computer applications, and mathematics at fifteen
sites in the state.
Tech Prep provides an educational path that leads to tomorrow. It integrates
college preparatory coursework with vocational and technical applications.
This planned sequence of courses begins in middle school and is articulated
to the community college degree program, resulting in an associate of applied
science degree. Through this unique program, Mississippi students can be
a part of a workforce that will ensure the state's ability to thrive in
the future. This program piloted fifteen sites in 1993-1994, established
fifty-one sites in 1994-1995, and funded an additional twenty-five sites
in 1995-1996. See Appendix J for additional information.
4.1.3 The New "Basic Skills" for the 21st Century
Literacy in the 21st Century no longer means merely the ability to read
printed material and write with a pencil. For the 21st Century a variety
of wide-ranging skills are needed that include the ability to navigate through
the maze of available information, to problem solve, and to think critically
utilizing a diverse array of technological tools.
Mississippi students must become proficient processors of information, developing
the ability to:
- access information from diverse sources
- analyze numerical, textual, and visual data
- communicate their findings to a variety of audiences.
Students must accept the responsibility and be armed with the skills to
become lifelong learners for individual success as well as the economic
stability and development of communities and districts within the state.
This requires that teachers interweave content, process, and technology
skills into a carefully planned quilt of instruction.
Technology integration is a catalyst for reforming education and creating
the new learning environments required to meet the challenges facing Mississippi's
educational systems in the 21st Century. The basis for using technology
in Mississippi's schools should be to promote various types of learning
including:
- inquiry-based
- interactive
- student-directed
- lifelong
- meaningful/real-world.
The use of a wide array of technological tools and applications in the classroom
enables educators to create a learning environment that provides the means
by which students:
- become responsible
- focus on identified learner outcomes
- engage in cooperative work efforts
- apply learning to real-life situations and experiences
- create their own knowledge structures through critical thinking, problem
solving and important decision making
- demonstrate progress and mastery of educational goals.
4.1.4 Impact of Education Technologies on Curriculum and Instruction
Examples of the positive impacts that innovative teaching and learning methods
can have on students exist already in parts of Mississippi. These models
need to be celebrated and replicated throughout the state. Leadership within
the state seeks to create a technologically-enriched educational system
statewide where students of all ages will exhibit a love for learning that
will carry them prosperously into adulthood. They will be risk takers in
their pursuit of knowledge, willing to venture into new arenas and apply
past experiences to new adventures. Mississippi students will become thinkers
and creators of new knowledge to coincide with and complement their ever-changing
world.
Early Elementary Students
More specifically, the readiness level of the second-grade student will
be exhibited by his/her emerging sense of self and developing independence.
Able to work independently and participate in small and large group activities,
this age child will immerse him/herself in rich exploratory environments.
Fundamental language arts, mathematics, and socialization skills are the
focus of attention in the early elementary years. This child is a "beginner"
in all areas, seeking to perfect a diverse array of skills while identifying
unique preferences and areas of strength.
The infusion of education technology into the early elementary classroom
has traditionally been used as a way to reinforce the use of traditional
manipulatives and hands-on resources via a medium that is well within the
learner's worldly experiences. Appropriate technology for primary schools
enables the child to engage in basic skill development in mathematics, reading,
writing, and other content areas through a wide assortment of technology
tools or instructional software. Computer-assisted instruction programs
provide a fun way for children to receive additional practice in basic skills
development. Primary learners are able to extend their language arts ability
through interactive engagement with CD-ROM stories, capture their imagination
by writing a story using a word processing program, or represent their creativity
by drawing or painting images graphically with a computer. Children who
demonstrate ease of use and an ability to utilize various forms of technology
should be provided further opportunities to extend their proficiencies with
technology simulations, real world and virtual field trips. Additionally,
providing young learners with access to education technology shows them
that computers and other mediums are an integral part of lifelong learning
and not an isolated element of their formal schooling.
Upper Elementary Students
Armed with the confidence of a full complement of basic language arts, mathematics,
and socialization skills, the third through fifth-grade student is interested
in a wealth of fleeting topics. Today it might be motorcycles and the planets,
tomorrow whales and hot air balloons. Carpe diem, "Seize the Day",
becomes the battle cry of the upper elementary classroom teacher. Provided
with a variety of resources, this learner is prepared to engage in both
semi-concrete and semi-abstract activities. The outcomes of his/her investigation
are always enlightening. Fascinated by the most unusual facts, this student
is an astute observer and processor of information.
A technologically-enriched environment nurtures intermediate-aged learners
to process information independently or cooperatively within small group
settings. Students are able to work collaboratively toward a common goal
by communicating with peers, teachers and parents through a variety of modes.
In addition, students are able to develop collectively class projects using
word processing, database, spreadsheets, desktop publishing, telecommunications,
or multimedia presentations, thereby representing the outcomes of their
learning. Thus, intermediate learners are able to expand the use of education
technology initially introduced in the primary setting by utilizing technology
in productive, creative formats.
Middle School Students
The middle school child will satisfy his/her need to socialize through increasingly
sophisticated collaborative efforts addressing authentic and pertinent issues.
While growing more aware of the world around him/her, the middle school
child juggles physical changes, growing responsibilities and expectations,
and emerging higher-order thinking skills. Successful experiences among
peers, during the middle school years, mold both the self-confidence and
self-esteem of this preadolescent.
Cooperative grouping and project-based learning activities provide the appropriate
learning conditions for middle school students to explore their own defined
educational pursuits. The incorporation of education technology further
enables exploration in group (or individual) projects and is limited only
by one's imagination (and the limitations of technology resources in the
classroom). Working in a learning environment where computer technology
is available further reinforces core concepts and principles through writing
practice and creative expression, information access, desktop publishing
activities, multimedia development and presentations, and the overall improvement
and mastery of computer competencies. The availability of computer technologies
for middle school students will further expand their capacities and skills
through an interdisciplinary approach to effective learning.
Junior High/High School Students
Students graduating from Mississippi high schools will face the next stage
of their lives with optimism, enthusiasm, excitement, and a sense of preparedness.
They will be confident in their knowledge of the world around them and their
ability to learn new skills which inevitably await them. Whether proceeding
on to higher education or entering the world of work, students from Mississippi
will exhibit a sense of community and responsible societal membership which
will serve them well in all environments.
Secondary schools need to accommodate the rapid changes across the world
by providing students with educational experiences that have real-life applications.
Many of these real-life experiences already include various aspects of using
technology. Thus, it is important that the secondary education learning
environment supports and nurtures collaborative efforts, provides access
to ideas and resources across disciplines as well as across the globe, and
encourages interdisciplinary instruction across the curriculum.
Some examples of real-life technology-oriented capabilities that should
be available to all Mississippi high school students include:
- accessing information from the school's media center by using an electronic
card catalog
- searching information beyond the school walls through "on-line"
telecommunications
- researching information on an encyclopedia stored on a CD-ROM compact
disk
- preparing for a math exam by using a graphing calculator
- drafting 3-D designs using the latest autocad, or computer-assisted
design program
- writing and publishing a newspaper or newsletter by using word processing,
graphics, scanning, and desktop publishing applications
- studying for an exam or preparing for a standardized test by reviewing
computer-assisted instruction programs in the form of tutorials, drill and
practice, simulations, or problem-solving activities
- creating a prototype of a community bank in which a school utilizes
sophisticated spreadsheet applications, complete with interest-bearing savings
accounts and possible loan distribution for those important events like
proms and homecoming dances
- developing multimedia presentations that include use of a still video
camera, CD-ROM or laserdisc player, and a VCR.
The above list represents only a small sample of technological possibilities
for schools. Examples of instructional disciplines currently incorporating
technology include:
- vocational education -- students gain experience with up-to-date
software currently used in business, such as state-of-the-art office automation
technologies
- biology and chemistry -- a variety of probes or measurement
devices interface with a computer and gather data automatically
- music and band -- computer systems are equipped with MIDI interfaces
so students can experience meter, rhythm, pitch, and volume to explore music
composition possibilities
- computer science -- students interested in formal programming
instruction and applications can create programs that may provide a foundation
for advanced college coursework in mathematics, engineering, or computer
science.
In addition to the specific examples cited above, many computer applications
are not discipline-specific. For example, innovative student creations in
the form of a hypermedia or multimedia presentation can easily be applied
for instructional purposes or developed for project-based learning. Subject
areas such as literature, social studies, math, foreign language, physical
education and health can all benefit from the computer applications readily
available for student use.
4.1.5 Integration Principles
Integrating technology into [today's classrooms] makes about as
much sense as integrating the internal combustion engine into the horse.
- Lewis Perelman, Discovery Institute
This quote is true if
Mississippians think of the classroom today in the traditional educational
sense - thirty desks in rows and the teacher lecturing at the front. Instead,
leadership suggests that technology should promote an environment where
learning can take place any time, from any place, and be available for everyone.
In this environment technology is a natural and integrated part of learning.
Students will acquire basic technological skills including word processing,
desktop publishing, databases, spreadsheets, computer graphics, electronic
communication, information management, interactive media, video, calculators,
and other specialized technologies while mastering curricular knowledge
and process skills (e.g., writing process, research process, scientific
process, mathematical modeling, and higher-order thinking).
Curriculum and technology integration can best be described as the alignment
of curricular objectives with technology competency milestones such that
students and teachers "learn about" technology by "teaching
and learning with technology". Technology competency milestones, such
as students in grade five can produce a document with word processing, provide
the direction for infusing technology tools and resources into appropriate
curriculum areas. This introduction of technology tools into daily learning
environments also allows teachers and students to simultaneously focus on
the process skills mentioned above. Thus, instructional activities across
the disciplines over time will reflect a marriage of content, technology,
and process skills.
Curriculum integration is an evolution, not an event. It is cyclical in
nature. The more students and teachers "learn about" the potential
of specific applications and technology resources, the more they will be
able to "teach and learn with" these powerful tools. Likewise,
as the number of instructional initiatives "teaching and learning with"
technology increases, the sophistication level of the users increases and
the need to know more "about " complex features and advanced applications
escalates.
Over time, the successful alignment of curriculum and technology brings
about observable changes in teaching and learning environments. Categorized
by Technology and Learning authors, Odvard Egil Dyrli and Daniel E. Kinnaman,
the impact of technology integration on the curricula will occur in three
progressive levels:
- enhancing and enriching the existing curricula using technology
within the confines of existing school structures and schedules;
- extending the existing curricula with technology by providing
opportunities beyond the limitations of school structures and schedules
without serious disruption; and,
- transforming the classroom curricula through technology in
ways that may require new paradigms, changes in organizational structures,
and innovative schedules of schooling.
For this progression toward systemic curriculum and technology integration
to occur, a well-orchestrated attack on three key conditions must be addressed
and nurtured at the district, school, and individual/personal levels:
- develop a clear technology vision for all Mississippi leadership and
educators
- align key variables
- manage technology resources.
Develop a Technology Vision
Stakeholder participation, one of the critical success factors in the technology
planning process, requires that the stakeholders have a clear and thorough
understanding of the state's technology vision. This vision must reflect
the state 's desire to use technology as a powerful vehicle to achieve the
21st Century reform efforts targeted as state and district priorities. State,
district, and school-based leadership, teachers, and parents of school-age
children must be able to articulate to the community at large the need for
education reform and the investment of time and monetary resources, as well
as patience with the process of change in schools across the state.
Development, articulation, and building support for state, district, and
school technology visions must become and remain a high priority for leadership
within the state.
Align Key Variables
A formidable task before leadership, curriculum and technology experts,
and professional development providers is the alignment of the following
key variables:
- curriculum objectives (content knowledge and process skills)
- student developmental needs
- student and teacher technology competencies
- district reform effort priorities
- school improvement plans
- professional development offerings.
The orchestration of aligning these variables will require guidance at the
state and district levels that includes participation from the Mississippi
Department of Education, superintendents, principals, teachers, and specialists,
while allowing for individualization at the district, school, and classroom
levels.
Technology integration principles that guide the incorporation of technology
into the curriculum result from a recognition of the evolutionary process
experienced as teachers gain confidence in the use of word processors, image
processors, databases, spreadsheets, graphic tools, idea processors, and
communication tools (i.e. the Internet and on-line services). These principles
represent structures required for initiating and sustaining progressive
curriculum integration over time.
The following are guiding principles of curriculum integration for Mississippi
educators:
- Technology will be integrated into all curricular areas and instructional
settings (K-12, vocational and adult education, exceptional education) and
preservice programs.
- The attainment of major curriculum reform will require the successful
infusion and integration of technology into teaching and learning environments.
- Curriculum reforms will be aligned with technology integration standards
embraced by national subject area leadership organizations like NSTA, NCTM,
NCTE, ISTE, etc., and their state-level affiliates.
- Technology integration will promote critical thinking, cooperative
learning, analysis and synthesis of information, interdisciplinary learning,
and improved communication skills.
- Successful integration of technology requires a change in the traditional
roles of teachers and students. Teachers become facilitators and students
become active participants.
- Technology will provide students with a tool for self-directed learning
and discovery.
- Technology will improve instructional delivery to help meet needs
for educational equity.
- Technology integration will bring a global perspective to schools
that have traditionally been very rural and isolated.
- Successful curriculum and technology integration implementation requires
sustained support and cooperation from all levels of administration.
- The integration of technology into the curriculum MUST begin with
adequate, appropriate, directed, and effective training. It must be supported
by continuous, ongoing professional development.
- Adequate funding and support must be in place for initial implementation
as well as ongoing system maintenance and upgrades.
- Adequate and sufficient funding must be provided for instructional
resources related to the implementation and interaction of technology.
- Student skill development in the use of technology tools will be integrated
into the curriculum. Skills will be blended into existing courses and NOT
taught as a separate subject. They include the use of productivity tools,
telecommunication tools, multimedia, authoring and publishing tools, on-line
networks, and electronic information resource tools.
- As technology is integrated into the curriculum, the teacher, parents,
administrators, and school boards must encourage and welcome changes in
student assessment methods.
- The development and installation of affordable connectivity to a statewide
network and other on-line network resources will assist all schools in all
districts with their curriculum integration initiatives.
4.1.6 Implementation Strategies
In the Information Age, the human beings that industry needs are
those who can do their own thinking, get actively involved, work in teams,
and be innovative, not merely industrious. The problem is, the factory model
school, which doesn't encourage those qualities, is still with us and needs
to be replaced with a new kind of schooling that does.
- Bill Blakemore, ABC News
Many districts aim to make technology
an integral part of the curriculum, seeing such integration as a means to
enhance academic achievement and promote learning among students. Technology
is seen as a positive enabling factor in both the delivery and management
of instruction, allowing schools to more appropriately address individual
learning needs and styles. The following implementation plan should serve
as a guideline for the state and districts alike as they take the leadership
role in supporting the curriculum integration needs of Mississippi schools.
- Office of Leadership & Professional Development will identify exemplary models of
technology integration and disseminate this information to help districts
and schools develop their own curriculum integration plans.
- Offices of Education Technology and Management Information Systems
will develop and make available, both in print and electronic formats, a
statewide database of curriculum integration resources including human and
material resources.
- Office of Leadership & Professional Development will work with other offices in the
MDE to establish curriculum integration guidelines linking appropriate technologies
to specific instructional activities.
- Office of Leadership & Professional Development will work with other offices in the
MDE to promote statewide curriculum integration projects across disciplines
through model instructional settings.
- Office of Leadership & Professional Development will work with other offices in the
MDE to embed core technology competencies throughout the curriculum.
- Office of Leadership & Professional Development will provide training opportunities
in curriculum integration strategies for educators at all instructional
levels, elementary, middle, and high school. Likewise, models will be identified
that demonstrate the changing roles of teachers and students. Professional
development training opportunities that focus on enabling teachers, administrators,
parents, and school board members to be comfortable in these ever-changing
learning environments will also be offered.
- Mississippi Department of Education will join forces with other state
and federal agencies on initiatives such as Goals 2000 and other programs
to expand, evaluate, and build upon their knowledge of curriculum reforms
in education technology as well as professional development alternatives
for the current teacher force.
- Local school districts will seek to develop and promote new school/business
partnerships that foster mutually beneficial relationships.
- Local school districts will schedule sufficient planning time for
teachers to learn how to use the technology.
- Schools will increase flexibility by allowing demand, need, and opportunity
to dictate schedules, instead of schedules dictating learning opportunities.
- Schools will investigate "buddy system" models where technology-proficient
students partner with younger students to assist with attaining fundamental
technology competencies, freeing the teacher to concentrate on integrating
these powerful technology tools into instructional tasks.
- Schools will encourage interdisciplinary courses and projects designed
around themes to create an authentic, seamless, and technology-oriented
curriculum.
4.2 Education Technology System Design
Businesses have been building electronic highways while education
has been creating an electronic dirt road. And sometimes on a dirt road
it is easier to just get out and walk.
- Fred D'Ignazio (1993)
The educational technology system design
involves wide-area networking, local-area networking, satellite interconnectivity,
ITFS, broadcast, interactive video, computer workstations, CD-ROM, videotape,
conventional telephone service, master television systems, and other classroom
technology. It is important to realize that education technology encompasses
any technology that enhances the educational process. In essence local learning
technologies, multimedia computers, local-area networks, CD-ROM drives,
video tape recorders, and videodiscs must be integrated with distance-learning
technologies, satellite, ITFS, interactive video (CCN, Fibernet, etc.),
television broadcast, and Internet access to create an effective high technology
learning environment.
The education technology system design represents a key part of the Mississippi
Master Plan for Education Technology. Recognizing this, the Council for
Education Technology appointed a special Telecommunications Committee to
study the following strategic areas: common needs, technical specifications
and network capacities, public awareness and dissemination of information,
and the development of state level capacity for future telecommunications
planning and coordination. The Telecommunications Committee and its subcommittees
(Common Needs, Technical Specifications, Public Information, and Concept)
presented a detailed report of their study to the Council its September
meeting (This report is presented in its entirety as an addendum to the
Master Plan).
Because of the broad scope of the education technology system design some
components come from several important studies conducted by the educational
entities. A network study prepared by Network Evolutions, Incorporated,
for the MIS Department at MDE; the Evan's Report, a technology plan for
the community and junior college system and the library system in the state;
and the IHL needs analysis documents on networking and distance learning
served as resources for the development of this section.
The Telecommunications Committee developed the following vision, mission,
and needs statements to guide the network design in concert with legislative
directives and intent.
Vision
The educational partners of public schools, community and junior colleges,
universities, educational television, libraries, and the state's Information
and Technology Services are committed to enhancing the quality of life for
Mississippians through lifelong learning by providing and integrating technology-based
communications and information systems to support all aspects of education.
The partners seek to establish a framework for the interconnectivity of
Mississippi networks and other networks to provide access to telecommunications
services. The partners pledge their resources to create educational and
economic opportunities for Mississippians today and tomorrow.
Mission
The partners are committed to creating, maintaining, and sustaining a technology
infrastructure that enables equitable and universal access to information
and services. Further, the technology should enhance Mississippi's efforts
in lifelong learning, research, economic development, and other quality-of-life
components through our collaborative efforts and strategic use of public/private
partnerships.
Needs
The educational partners acknowledge the ever-increasing pace of a changing,
global society. Therefore, we identify the following needs which must (or
should) be addressed by improving communication and technology services:
- Improve educational offerings for citizens of the state of Mississippi
by designing an integrated, technology-based communications and information
system to support all aspects of education. Citizens to be served include,
but are not limited to educational entities, students, parents, communities,
business/industry, and governmental agencies.
- Enhance efficiency in the delivery of education and information services.
- Ensure that the services are offered in an equitable manner.
- Ensure that the services are affordable for all end-users.
- Encourage information sharing and common needs identification among
various entities.
- Reduce duplication of services where missions converge.
- Develop a flexible system that can easily be modified, upgraded, and
expanded to accommodate connectivity, future growth, and development.
- Improve the quality and quantity of technology tools.
- Ensure that a variety of technological tools are available to enhance
the learning process.
4.2.1 Education Technology System Architecture
Mississippi's education technology system architecture should be needs driven
and address the design and implementation of various technologies in the
classroom, and school, distance-learning technologies, and local and wide-area
networking.
Classroom technologies, or user interfaces (e.g., multimedia computers,
television receivers, projection systems, telephones, fax machines) and
other technologies that link the learner to information should all be considered
when designing the high technology classroom.
The education technology system architecture should:
- maximize learning efficiency and economy by matching the technology
to the need
- create the proper learning environment by addressing ergonomics, the
elimination of distractions, and aesthetics
- create the most user-friendly interface possible
- minimize the cost of interconnectivity by exploring all options
- enable universal access--a concept that states that the network architecture
and costs associated with the network should be affordable and equitable
- be location insensitive--areas of the state must not be penalized
for their rurality
- support vendor independence--the network design should be open for
competition among providers. Components of the networks should be vendor
independent as well, in platform and software
- create a system of maintenance and support and a funding mechanism
for same
- be based on interoperability--the network design should support multiple
platforms and technologies. It should be transparent to the user and neutral
in terms of ownership
- be application driven--the network should develop and adapt around
the needs of the users, those who provide the "programming" and
those who create the applications
- consider financial resources for system sustainability
- adhere to telecommunication standards recommended by the Technical
Specifications Subcommittee.
In summary, the network must serve the end-user in terms of the following:
- cost--reduce cost where practical without limiting connectivity
- ease of migration--allow for a smooth implementation of the
network services
- ease of management--allow for centralized management and scheduling
of the network
- scalability--enable the network to grow
- expandability--enable a site to expand its capabilities
- proven technology--use currently available and proven technology.
Distance learning is an important aspect of the education technology system
design. Included in the definition of distance learning is the process of
providing instruction to students that are unable to receive instruction
at their location. New technologies and delivery systems can provide various
levels of interactive distance learning anywhere in the nation or the world.
Essentially, the education technology system architecture should incorporate
new technologies that enhance learning within the classroom environment,
such as:
- multimedia computer workstations (information resource interface)
- classroom computer networking (local-area networks)
- wide-area networks
- distance learning technologies
- satellite distribution
- ITFS-Instructional Television Fixed Service
- broadcast television
- interactive video.
4.2.2 General Design Principles
The following general principles must govern the education technology system
design:
Adequate and Economical Service
Each of the educational entities is to have access to the connectivity capacity
required to provide an economical education technology network with seamless
interoperability without duplication of resources.
Equipment Standards and Guidelines
Equipment standards and operational guidelines are to be developed and integrated
throughout the network. Standards will be updated at least annually, or
as needed, with input gathered from each agency as to needs, capacities,
and proposed revisions.
Standard Protocols
The key to interoperability will be the standardization of data and video
communications protocols and a high degree of coordination and cooperation
among the agencies. TCP/IP is currently the international standard for data
communications over the Internet which provides for international interoperability.
Therefore all agencies should agree to conform to this protocol standard
for data communications and future video standards established by ITS and
the Council for Education Technology.
4.2.3 Application Principles
A broad array of software packages must be available to every student, instructor,
administrator, and citizen that will meet their common application needs.
Provisions must be made to purchase statewide software licenses and to keep
application software up-to-date. The selected hardware must have the flexibility
to meet the broad range of educational applications that exist today and
in the future across the entire education spectrum.
4.2.3.1 Technology Utilization
Technology utilization is dependent upon informed choices which define patterns
of software, hardware, and peripheral devices installed to augment instruction
and support classroom, school, and district level data management and reporting
functions. The following patterns are offered as guides to assist local
districts in the acquisition of hardware and software systems.
Classroom Clusters
Technology within the typical K-12 classroom should include a cluster of
computers at a ratio of one computer to every five children. Each computer
is to be connected to a "server-based" local area network system
within the school that is designed around state-of-the-art networking hardware
and software utilizing the star network topology and 10BaseT technologies.
In selected classrooms additional computer peripherals will be required
to meet specific subject area requirements such as data collection probes
for real time monitoring of science experiments, etc. All classrooms should
be equipped with a multimedia-based computer to serve as a teacher workstation
and it should be connected to a display system to support easy viewing of
displayed information by all students. This workstation must be appropriately
designed and equipped specifically to support the daily delivery of instruction.
All network wiring should be Category 5 and installed to 100 Mbps standards.
Workstations do not have to be the traditional desktop variety. These
"desktop computers" could be laptops. The availability, affordability,
and practicality of having a tool that weighs less than 10 pounds and that
can be easily checked out for overnight use is beneficial. Districts should
consider seriously the purchase of laptops to be placed in the media center
for student/staff checkout and use.
The classroom clusters configuration is recommended for schools.
Computer Laboratories
In those schools where clusters of computers within classrooms are not deemed
appropriate to support the instructional environment, the computer "laboratory
approach" may be utilized although this is not recommended
as the sole implementation configuration. Under this arrangement a group
of 20 to 25 computer workstations are to be located in a classroom that
is designed to provide an appropriate work environment for a large group
of students working on such things as science and writing projects. Under
the laboratory arrangement a ratio of one student per computer should be
maintained at all times. A typical computer lab containing 25 computers
should contain no less than 1200 square feet of space, adequate sound conditioning,
carpet, ergonomically-designed furniture to accommodate an array of different
ages and sizes of children, appropriate and adequate lighting, and sufficient
air conditioning to handle the additional heat load generated by the workstations.
Computer labs are to serve as general purpose facilities designed to meet
a broad range of educational needs within the school and community. In selected
situations, where conditions require, additional equipment may be added
to the laboratory to meet the specific needs of specialized user groups.
Each computer lab is to meet the same design and performance requirements
as previously outlined for classroom computer clusters. See Appendix H for
three typical laboratory arrangements. Also see Appendix D for workstation
and local-area network specifications.
Local-Area Networks - Building Networks
Each existing building and all new buildings within a school district should
be wired to support computer connections in all classrooms to the local-area
network. Structured wiring systems designed to accommodate current and future
needs should be implemented in all buildings to carry both data and video
signals. Wiring conduits and raceways should be installed throughout all
school buildings to provide access for the installation of new wiring systems
as network demands expand. Building network configurations should be designed
as star topologies using 10BaseT Ethernet technologies. All wiring should
extend from classrooms and offices to network hubs installed in designated
wiring closets. Network maps should be developed and all cables should be
logically labeled and documented in the appropriate network drawing. The
network should be designed as a "server-based" network with all
software installed on the file server and not on individual workstations.
Hubs located in different wiring closets should be connected with fiber-optic
cables which contain additional pairs of fibers designated for applications
in the future. All network wiring should be Category 5 and installed to
100 Mbps standards. See Appendix D for local-area network specifications.
Extended Local-Area Networks - Campus Networks
On school campuses where more than one building is located in close proximity
(on the same campus) the local-area network should be extended to provide
access across the entire campus. This should be accomplished by networking
all computers throughout all buildings and establishing centralized wiring
closets in each building to accommodate network wiring hubs. Buildings should
be interconnected with fiber-optic cable to keep within Ethernet transmission
distance standards and to prevent network and workstation damage from lightning
strikes. All network wiring should be Category 5 and installed to 100 Mbps
standards. See Appendix D for local-area network specifications.
Wide-Area Networks - District Networks
In school districts where buildings are located on different campuses attention
must be given to interconnecting the local-area networks found on each campus
into a wide-area network to provide systemwide communications capability.
The interconnections between different campuses can be accomplished in a
variety of ways. Each school district should investigate all telecommunications
capabilities that exist within their region and select the most cost-effective
technology to meet their needs. Current possibilities include leased telecommunications
lines (56KB and T-1 lines) supplied by the local telephone company, existing
TV cable systems capable of bi-directional communications, district-owned
fiber-optic cables extended between schools, or telecommunications lines
owned by power utility companies, banks, industries, etc. Costs for the
use of these telecommunications facilities vary considerably from area to
area. It is recommended that a careful and thorough study be made by the
district prior to selecting any telecommunications alternative. Partnerships
with other groups and organizations have proven to be most beneficial in
other areas of the country and within Mississippi over the past few months.
See Appendix D for wide-area network specifications.
Network Traffic Consolidation Plan
Careful consideration should be given to the development of cooperative
relationships with other organizations and agencies that foster the development
of a "shared" telecommunications "backbone." Under an
arrangement of this type network traffic can be consolidated to provide
a significant reduction in operational and transmissions costs. A backbone
design should be considered that provides the capability for local schools
to connect to a hub site located in close proximity, such that monthly line
costs are kept within reason for the typical school budget. This can be
accomplished by having area hubs established widely across the state which
will in turn be connected to regional hubs that provide economy of scale
in transmission capabilities. All regional hubs may be connected to a state
access point or central networking center to gain access to the Internet
and other regional resources at adequate transmission speeds to serve the
extended needs across Mississippi.
4.2.4 Workstations
Workstation specifications and networking standards will be developed by
the Technical Specifications Committee to be submitted to the Council for
adoption and distribution. Network standards and workstation specifications
will be reviewed by the committee and updated on an annual basis with input
from a cross section of network users and participating agencies. See Appendix
D for sample workstation specifications and networking standards.
4.2.4.1 Classroom of The Future
Minimum standards for classrooms of the future include components beyond
hardware and software including:
- a prepared instructor
- students motivated to learn
- TV and VCR with cable, ITFS, and satellite downlink access
- voice communication line access (phone)
- wide-area network access (including Internet)
- multimedia system *see Appendix D more information
- electronic presentation/projection system
- interactive video system.
4.2.4.2 Administrative Computing
Workstations for administrators will be interconnected with local-area networks
(LANs) and used to transfer student records as well as provide e-mail, file
sharing, and database transactions between schools, district, regional,
and state offices.
4.2.4.3 Instructional Computing
Instructional computing will primarily be confined to the classrooms and
buildings on the school premises through local-area networks created through
the use of file servers. Servers and routers will be configured for the
most efficient network operation and will aid in preventing data directed
to local workstations from spilling onto the wide-area network. Teachers
will access the network to exchange information with other educators, to
complete administrative tasks, and to gather research information.
4.2.5 Networking Services and Levels (data)
Networking services and levels are based upon the speed of delivery of information
to the user. Interconnectivity system levels include the following:
- dialup Internet access
- 56 kbps Internet access
- 1.544 mbps (T1) access
- 45 mbps (DS3) access.
These levels of network service must be matched with user requirements and
available funding to ensure maximum efficiency and effectiveness. In some
cases dialup access may be the only affordable solution even though it will
severely limit the user's access to graphics on Internet.
The most viable delivery speeds, when considering cost and speed, are 56
Kbps and 1.544 Mbps. Current rates for DS3 service levels are cost prohibitive.
T1 is currently the best balance between cost and service.
4.2.6 Technology Management System
Technology management should be accomplished on the local and organizational
level. Key items that should be addressed are as follows:
- development of network standards and guidelines
- implementation of the distance learning component and plan
- network support and maintenance
- emerging technology development responsibilities
- forecasting and planning
- training
- accountability and evaluation.
4.2.7 Information Security and Privacy
Information systems, LANs and WANs, must provide a reasonable amount of
security for protection against unwanted intrusions. The primary level of
security is the user's password. File servers will aid in system security
by acting as a gatekeeper allowing access and distributing information.
The primary barrier to intrusion is password and account-level protection.
Districts must address security issues and have policies regarding information
security and privacy in place when implementing networked systems. Once
districts connect to the Internet, these issues take on even greater significance.
4.2.8 Telecommunications
Telecommunications is an integral part of the education technology system
design in that it is the link that provides information exchange between
users, instructors, and instructional providers. Fiber optics, copper wire,
satellite, broadcast, and ITFS delivery systems will be the telecommunications
pipelines that will interconnect computer workstations and facilitate distance
learning. The Telecommunications Specifications and Operational Capacities
Subcommittee Report that appears as the addendum to this document offers
recommendations and guidance on telecommunications.
4.2.8.1 Data Communications
Each educational entity will proceed with plans for its own statewide network,
tailored to meet its specific educational and administrative needs, but
with a high degree of universal planning, coordination, and cooperation
under the direction of the Council and ITS. Under this plan, each entity
will maintain a high percentage of autonomy and prerogative in tailoring
a network to meet its specific educational requirements, while simultaneously
adhering to certain mutually agreed upon standards, policies and practices
ensuring interoperability and avoiding waste and duplication of resources.
Obviously, the success of this strategy rests upon the effectiveness of
the planning and coordination. Much thought and deliberation should be given
to the structure, composition and responsibility of the guiding entities.
Representatives from K-12, the State Board for Community and Junior Colleges,
the Institutions of Higher Learning, the Mississippi Library Commission,
Mississippi Educational Television and ITS would seem appropriate partners.
Given the fact that technology is a moving target and is changing at a rapid
pace, it would be unwise to specify a detailed set of technical specifications
in this document for an educational information network, since such specifications
would become dated as soon as written. In light of this, a generic set of
specifications that can evolve as technologies emerge has been presented.
Where appropriate, specific technical recommendations based upon current
technology and communications protocols are offered to direct the project
toward a concerted effort.
The recommended data communications protocol is TCP/IP, the Internet model.
The Internet model is recognized as the de facto standard for wide-area
networking nationally and internationally.
4.2.8.2 Video Communications
The recommended video communications protocol is MPEG-2 for high quality
video destined for television or ITFS broadcast, or delivery for video program
post production.
The recommended video teleconferencing standard for use on interactive video
networks operating below the T1 level is the VTEL algorithm, since this
standard is now in universal use by the state's educational interactive
video networks. All equipment should also be capable of operating with the
H.320 video compression standard. The recommended video operating standard
is 768 Kbps at 30 frames per second.
4.2.8.3 Interconnectivity Service
Interconnectivity should be developed through a carefully planned process
of creating the most efficient and cost effective infrastructure. Options
should be explored to help offset interconnectivity costs. Where it is necessary
to obtain interconnectivity from telecommunications providers, an RFP should
be developed through the cooperative efforts of the Mississippi Department
of Education, State Board of Community and Junior Colleges, Library Commission,
Institutions of Higher Learning, Mississippi Authority for Educational Television,
and Information Technology Services to eliminate duplication of services
and to reduce costs through collective procurement.
4.2.9 Critical Needs
Support
With a large undertaking that ties many sites together with varying degrees
of expertise ranging from none to expert, it is critical to draw a plan
to provide for the uniform support of both hardware and software for all
users and systems administrators. If any technology-based delivery system
is to be successful and self-sustaining, a significant support function
must be provided. The following needs to be established in order to provide
equitable and reasonable support for all concerned:
- regional help desks/service centers
- trained local support personnel
- ongoing user seminars and classes in technology
- training for teachers in curriculum integration for technology
- adequate training for an appropriate number of technical personnel
- support systems for monitoring and managing the infrastructure
Maintenance
Hardware and software maintenance is critical to continued use and success
of this project. A fixed percentage of local school budgets must be allocated
to maintain equipment within classrooms. State and regional monies must
be allocated to continue maintenance and operation of WAN and LAN infrastructures.
Maintenance issues that need to be addressed include:
- Hardware support contracts--using both locally and regionally
based service organizations to leverage best buying power for service contracts
- Standardization of hardware platforms--makes it easier to acquire
spares and effect local repairs in a timely fashion
- Software support--"Shrink wrapped" software is usually
supported by vendor customer support organizations. However if sufficient
quantity is purchased through a standard application definition, "preferred
status" can often be achieved and dedicated vendor support can be negotiated.
- Upgrades--volume buying and standardization of software packages
can help minimize these costs and provide ease of installation for support
personnel.
- Obsolescence plan--needs to be developed to allow the graceful
retirement of equipment and the purchase of replacement hardware with minimal
financial burden.
Training
A technological infrastructure without properly trained individuals is of
little value. It is imperative that a significant portion of all available
resources be invested in the citizens of Mississippi in the form of training.
Therefore, a commitment must be made to provide relevant up-to-date training
on an ongoing basis at all levels.
Sustainability
Sustainability remains an area of critical need. The infusion of technology
into the classroom will require ongoing resources. Currently, there are
no consistent procedures or sources to support education technology in the
state and few districts are able to direct sufficient local funds to make
a difference.
4.2.10 Implementation Strategies
Goal
The creation of an effective education technology network is highly dependent
on the interconnecting of fiber, wired, and wireless network technology
to create a wide area network that reaches every user with the greatest
efficiency and economy. It is our recommendation that this concept be a
priority. It is also most important to match the delivery system to the
need.
Wide-Area Networking for Data and Interactive Video
The Institutions of Higher Learning, Mississippi Department of Education,
State Board for Community and Junior Colleges, Mississippi Educational Television,
the Mississippi Library Commission, and Information Technology Services
are committed to work together to ensure interoperability and network interconnectivity
to ensure effective, efficient, and economical networking without duplication
of services. Formal plans should be made to ensure that the Council on Education
Technology continues to provide ongoing coordination, management, policy
recommendations, and accountability. Through commitment to such a plan,
the Council should continue to secure input and advice from private sector
representatives, educational practitioners, and others as required to ensure
broad-based input. The Council shall continue to establish advisory committees
as needed. Administrative and support services for the Council on Education
Technology should be provided by one of the agencies as determined by the
Council for Education Technology.
Procurement of Interconnectivity
The Institutions of Higher Learning, the State Board for Community and Junior
Colleges, Mississippi Educational Television, the Mississippi Library Commission,
the Mississippi Department of Education, and ITS should work together to
investigate interconnectivity options, and where needed, create a process
to retain network interconnectivity and switching from a qualified telecommunications
provider(s) to ensure effective, efficient, and economical networking without
duplication of services. Careful attention should be paid to the fact that
in the near future there may be more competition in the telecommunications
marketplace if proposed federal legislation is enacted that could precipitate
lower interconnectivity costs. The possibility of lower costs warrants caution
when entering into long-term contracts that may lock in charges even though
lower cost services become available.
Technology Monitoring
The Technical Specifications Subcommittee should be maintained under the
Council for Education Technology. This committee will monitor emerging technologies,
evaluate new technologies that could benefit education technology networking,
and make recommendations to the Council concerning the technical aspects
of the networks and the need for additional communications standards and
capacity.
Establishment of Local User Groups
Local user and coordinator groups should be established by each entity to
ensure that the local area networks are operating effectively from a technical
standpoint.
Establishment of Wide-Area User Groups
A wide-area user group should be established by each entity to monitor the
technical and operational aspects of the wide-area network provided by the
telecommunications provider.
Interactive Video Network Scheduling
A system of coordination (especially for video networking ) should be developed
by those entities operating interactive video networks that will aid in
scheduling of classes and networking and serve as a mechanism for information
exchange between each entity's interactive video coordinator.
Design and Operation of Systems
The State Board for Community and Junior Colleges and the Institutions of
Higher Learning currently operate both local and wide-area networks and
have the expertise to design and operate these networks. However, given
the number of network sites within K-12 and the purchasing autonomy of the
K-12 schools, the potential for special challenges exists in the deployment
of a statewide K-12 network of this magnitude. Special consideration should
be given to coordination in the design, installation, and equipment procurement
process, as well as to the continuing support of this component of the statewide
educational network.
Maintenance and Support
The entities should establish maintenance and support plans that consolidate
services to reduce costs and request funding and generate revenue, where
feasible, to fund these to important tasks.
Feedback
A system of feedback should be established to ensure the wide area network
is functioning at high efficiency without duplication of service. This will
also serve as a mechanism for gathering input from users to identify areas
in need of improvement.
Installation Procedures
Installation procedures should be formulated by each entity to create consistent
and quality facilities.
Equipment Procurement
Purchase versus lease and other purchasing criteria should be carefully
evaluated by the educational entities and ITS to ensure the best economy
and equipment procurement.
Detailed Specifications
A more detailed set of plans should be formulated addressing classroom equipment
and infrastructure, wide area connectivity, and other technical considerations.
Timeline for Implementation
A timeline for implementation of classroom technology and wide-area networking
should be developed. The classroom and school models outlined in this section
should be addressed, along with the technology implementation phases outlined
in the Distance Learning Section.
4.3 Education Accountability and Reporting System
Design
The continued support of an initiative often requires that the school or
district first offer evidence of its success. Accountability refers to the
ability and responsibility of measuring results as a means by which to account
for expenditures and the use of other resources. Reporting is defined as
the collection of this measurable information arranged in a specific format
for a particular individual or group. The collection, analysis, and reporting
of data involves some of the most labor-intensive routines performed by
administrators and teachers. Access to technologies that provide for full
maintenance, reporting, and accountability can make the administration of
these and other related tasks much more manageable.
4.3.1 Design Principles
The components of a statewide data collection system will be developed according
to the following design principles:
- Both current and future electronic data collection systems will be
utilized. This will enhance the ability of the MDE to provide more accurate
and timely reports for review and analysis by educators, legislators, business
leaders, parents and other key stakeholders.
- Use of the MONEX network will assist in the management of administrative
processes at the local level. This will reduce paperwork and allow more
local staff time to be spent on direct instruction and services to children.
- Database components will be a part of the MDE database system in which
pre-determined fields and definitions remain consistent among projects.
This consistency will provide for aggregation of data at the state level
as well as a means by which to compare districts.
- Data that is requested on a routine basis should be retrievable in
predetermined report formats. The predetermined report formats will provide
easy access to information and should assist stakeholders in obtaining educational
data. These formats will be designed to provide timely feedback on student
performance and achievement as measured against state, local, and national
norms and standards. This information will be accessible to teachers, administrators
and staff at school, district, and state levels.
4.3.2 Existing Programs
The Mississippi Department of Education uses MONEX (Mississippi Online Network
Exchange), a dialup modem system of collecting and disseminating data to
and from local school districts. All school districts within Mississippi
have access to MONEX at the district central office administrative level.
Additionally, some districts have expanded opportunities for access to all
schools within the district through local-area and wide-area networks.
Current projects that are supported on MONEX and the Office of Management
Information Systems include:
- local educational agency personnel reporting program
- vocational education system, teacher certification program, financial
reporting, attendance reporting
- school board member data collection system
- electronic school calendar system
- child nutrition food distribution system
- child nutrition claims payment system.
4.3.3 Implementation Strategies
The following stategies will be employed to guide the development of information
systems
- The MDE will continue to convert the data collection, dissemination,
and reporting procedures to standardized electronic data transfer format.
- The MDE will continue to expand the existing electronic reporting
systems.
- The MDE will establish stringent deadlines for the development of
new systems (see Table 4-1) including the following:
A student-level database program, which will fulfill the needs of the performance-based
accreditation model, will provide for uniform data collection efforts for
all students in the state. It will allow the state to collect data at the
student level for dropout reports, graduation, and other specific reporting
purposes. Efforts are underway to allow districts the ability to share aggregate
district data with the state in order to aid in the reduction of the current
paperload requirements on district administrators and teachers. Additional
functionality includes electronic records transfer and tools to track student
performance by grade and classroom. The projected date of completion is
July, 1997.
The special education monitoring and individualized educational plan (IEP)
database is designed to be a comprehensive system to fully automate the
special education state and federal data collection requirements and to
assist local education agencies in IEP development. The purpose of the project
is to improve the quality of data reporting and to reduce the paper flow
between the MDE and districts, as well as to improve efficiency at the local
level. This program has been expanded to include performance variables for
the performance-based accreditation system. The projected date of completion
is July, 1996.
A textbook inventory and tracking system will be developed to track state-owned
textbooks and provide an electronic medium for the timely transfer of textbooks
between school districts. This system will reduce paperwork flowing between
districts and provide an accurate account of textbooks available throughout
the state.
Table 4-1: Education Accountability and Reporting System Design Schedule
EDUCATION ACCOUNTABILITY
AND REPORTING SYSTEM DESIGN SCHEDULE
Electronic Calendar Sep 30, 1995
Teacher Certification Sep 30, 1995
Enhanced Personnel Reporting Nov 1, 1995
Textbook Inventory Jul 1, 1995
Special Education Database Jul 1, 1996
Vocational Education Database Jul 1, 1997
Student-Level Database Jul 1, 1997
- The MDE will provide Internet access for all districts to ensure adequate
networking capacity as resources permit.
- The MDE will use the World-Wide Web and FTP services on the Internet
as a central distribution point for connectivity and file sharing among
districts. This includes continued expansion and development of the MDE
Home Page. The utilization of this system could encourage local districts
to develop home pages which might promote access to data by parents and
community leaders.
- The MDE will review the capabilities of emerging technologies to ensure
the continued expansion of the data system. It will also upgrade the technical
capacity required to address these new technologies and increased reporting
requirements.
4.4 Learning Environments and Facilities Planning
4.4.1 Introduction/Needs/Retrofitting
Overview
The implementation of new technologies precipitates the need to create appropriate
environments for both users and equipment. Users need ergonomically-designed
spaces that offer environmental comfort, appropriate lighting, low ambient
noise level, security and easy access to both the overall technology environment
and workstation equipment. An emphasis must be placed on reducing work-related
injuries (carpal tunnel syndrome, eyestrain etc.). Equipment must also have
an appropriate environment to ensure maximum efficiency of use, and to protect
equipment from premature failure.
Planning for the Future
During facility renovation, new construction, or equipment installation,
future technology requirements should always be considered. Installation
of additional electrical power sources and wiring can make room for future
equipment and thus eliminate the need to renovate when the new equipment
is installed. In most cases, the infrastructure cabling represents a small
cost to the project. The major cost is labor for installation.
New Construction
During the design phase of new schools and new building additions on campuses,
architects should involve professionals who specialize in the areas of electrical
design to ensure adequate power and power protection for computing and other
equipment, voice, video and data network cabling, lighting, and especially
in the case of interactive video classrooms, ambient noise level. Space
must also be planned to house specialized equipment.
These same considerations should be addressed when designing new campus
facilities to be used exclusively for education technology.
Remodeling and Renovation
When existing spaces must be renovated or remodeled to accept new technology,
the needs assessment must be performed. Electrical power systems should
be evaluated to ensure adequate power is available and that grounding is
compliant for workstations. Also, air conditioning systems should be inspected
to determine the ability to provide the additional cooling to handle the
increased heat load presented by a number of workstations.
4.4.2 Design Principles
The design principles employed when creating appropriate learning environments
and facilities should be based upon established national standards. Entities
(e.g., ITS, IHL, and ETV) that have experience in retrofitting buildings
to accept equipment requiring specialized environments must work in coordination
with other educational entities to share their expertise on a consulting
basis, and also help in the development of a facilities installation document.
Special consideration should be given to manufacturer's installation recommendations.
Since many school campuses are involved in the technology implementation
process, a needs analysis must be done on a case-by-case basis to determine
the appropriate location for new technology sites, as well as the need for
renovation and remodeling, new construction, ergonomics, and electrical
and mechanical considerations.
Learning Environment Considerations
Lighting, room acoustics, ambient noise levels, and ergonomics should be
addressed when considering the environmental aspects of learning environments.
Ergonomics can play a major role in increasing learning efficiency. Proper
lighting and other environmental considerations all play a part in creating
the most comfortable and safe learning environment. Workstations should
be placed on desks specifically designed for computer use. Keyboards and
monitors should be properly installed to ensure proper viewing angles and
proper keyboard tilt to help eyestrain and typing fatigue. Seating should
be ergonomically designed and offer proper support for extended periods
of workstation operation.
Computer workstations require special room lighting considerations to reduce
screen glare and the resulting eye fatigue. Most older buildings have fluorescent
lights with omni-directional diffusers. These must be replaced with parabolic
diffusers to reduce glare on the monitor face to reduce eye fatigue.
Low ambient noise levels are particularly important in computer labs and
interactive video equipped classrooms. Workstations in computer labs generate
noise from fan motors. As the number of workstations increases so does the
fan noise. Acoustic absorption material can be placed on the walls to absorb
some of this noise. This is particularly important in interactive video
classrooms where microphones pick up student responses.
Good room acoustics are very important to provide speech intelligibility.
The selection of wall material is important to help reduce echo. Highly
reverberant rooms make speech intelligibility poor, making it difficult
for the instructor to hear questions or responses by students. Wall treatment
cost is low when considering the important improvements it would make.
Power Source Considerations
In pre-existing structures, electrical power sources for computer workstation,
interactive video, and other equipment should be evaluated for proper voltage,
current availability, and grounding. Older structures may not have properly
grounded outlets or adequate current. A licensed electrician should be employed
to evaluate electrical power and provide a written report insuring compliance
with electrical codes for computer equipment. Adequate surge protection
should also be installed to protect against equipment damage from lightning
and power line voltage surges. For system such as servers and network control
devices such as routers and bridges, an Uninterruptable Power Supply (UPS)
should be considered. Critical function/task workstations should also be
considered for this feature.
Aesthetic Considerations
An aesthetically pleasing environment creates a pleasant atmosphere for
students and instructors. This is particularly true in interactive video
classrooms where local, as well as network, participants view the classrooms.
In many cases a classroom may contain the finest high technology equipment,
but poor installation practices may create a look that is far from high
tech. Wall and floor colors, hidden wiring, and the lack of clutter will
create a neat installation that will offer students and visitors a pleasing
environment that will create a good impression. Creating a good look may
also enhance the possibility of future funding.
4.4.3 Implementation Strategies
Implementation strategies revolve around the development of models for computer
labs, interactive video classrooms, and other technology facilities. If
districts do not have the local expertise to create a high technology environment,
either a model must be developed as a guide for implementation, or equipment,
facilities, and building modifications must be handled from a central source,
to ensure standards compliance and consistency. The following steps can
be utilized to implement new education technology.
- Once all technologies and the location for those technologies has
been confirmed, a needs assessment should be conducted.
- A model should be developed to serve as a guide for equipment installation,
facility renovation, and ergonomic considerations.
- A syllabus should be drafted as an information resource and guide
for local staff during the implementation process.
- Once equipment has been installed and facilities have been renovated,
staff should be designated to inspect the new facilities to ensure vendor
and contractor compliance and to ensure that the facility meets specified
criteria.
- The technical appendices should be distributed to the school sites
involved.
4.4.4 Learning Environment Details
Classrooms
- Each classroom should have connectivity for all media (data, voice,
and video).
- Classrooms should be fitted with 24" (or larger) TV monitors
for video to be used in conjunction with CPU-TV adapters/converters for
classroom demonstrations.
- Classrooms with more than one computer should be designed to facilitate
easy access by small work groups of students (i.e., 2-5 students per workstation)
to permit sharing of resources.
- Controllable/adjustable lighting is important to provide suitable
lighting levels for viewing either TV broadcasts or computer monitors.
- Temperature needs to be maintained to protect equipment from failure
and also to provide comfort for students.
Computer Labs
- Labs need to be designed to provide sufficient electrical power and
temperature control to protect equipment.
- Work space should be designed to allow sufficient space for text books
and other materials needed while working with computers.
- A large TV monitor should be provided for teacher workstations to
enable demonstrations to large groups.
- Space needs to be allocated for printers, scanners, and other dedicated
input/output devices that can be shared in lab work.
- A lab should be wired with 10% extra (spare) network ports during
initial installation to allow for unexpected growth, and to provide contingencies
for untimely failure of a line.
- Acoustics must be carefully considered as a large number of computers
in a room can generate a significant amount of noise. Depending on the sound-dampening
qualities of the room, it is possible to exceed safe OSHA-recommended sound
pressure levels. The environment should be designed/tested by a qualified
sound engineer.
Media Centers
- Workstations (as well as CD-ROM towers, scanners, printers, etc.)
should have sufficient room about them to allow placement of reference materials
and workbooks.
- Computer reference material (CD-ROMs, disks) should be readily accessible
to users.
- Lighting and acoustics must be addressed (see above).
- A sufficient number of media (voice, data, video) ports should be
placed as needed.
- Many times media centers are used for class presentations. Access
to both the video and data network is important in facilitating these functions.
- Media Centers should provide extra network connections at reading
tables for personal laptop computers to enable access to networked-based
library materials (card catalogues, CD-ROM servers, Internet).
4.5 Distance Learning
4.5.1 Introduction
Distance learning is a broadly used term that has come to refer to several
situations where there is a geographical separation between the learner
and the teacher/instructor. Generally speaking, distance education takes
place when a teacher and students are separated by physical distance, and
technology is used to bridge the instructional gap.
For the purposes of this plan, the term distance learning is used to refer
to an organized system of delivering educational information and materials
between two or more geographically separated sites through a variety of
transmission modes. In some systems, there is immediate feedback through
telephone, FAX, two-way video and audio, or computer connections. Other
systems have delayed feedback. The terms "distance education"
and "distance learning" are used interchangeably in the plan.
Why distance learning?
Distance learning offers a broad range of technology to serve a wide
range of educational functions and makes lifelong learning opportunities
accessible and more affordable. As cited by the Council of Chief State School
Officers in its report, Education and Instruction Through Telecommunications,
increasing numbers of schools are taking advantage of distance learning
opportunities for their students for several reasons: declining student
enrollment (particularly in rural areas), declining student performance,
increasing transportation costs, otherwise unavailability of courses, equal
access to educational opportunities, and taking advantage of the most efficient
use of limited funds and resources.
What can distance learning achieve?
Distance learning has many advantages that can contribute to the achievement
of Mississippi education goals. Among those advantages are: providing instruction
to learners at remote sites on subject matter not readily available; enhancing
course content through offerings such as electronic field trips and visits
to resource-rich environments; connecting school-based learning to applications
in the workplace; providing staff development and school management capabilities
not available through other means; and supporting lifelong training from
day-care worker support to adult literacy and higher education.
Distance learning will link homes, schools, libraries, and community centers
with the emerging national information infrastructure.
The need for educational programming providers
Distance education offers a method of sharing resources across the state
or across a school district. While this section focuses on the technology
delivery systems, a strategy must be developed to provide educational programs
for distance learning in Mississippi. Providing the technology without providing
an avenue to develop instructional programming will seriously undermine
the distance education effort in the state. Mississippi needs a wide variety
of program providers to deliver instructional programs over a wide variety
of technologies. Instructional providers can be K-12 teachers, community
and junior colleges, university faculty, ETV, or may be purchased from other
educational consortium. Funding for distance education is discussed in the
funding issues and strategies section.
Appropriateness of technologies
Technology delivery should be determined by the curriculum and by student
and district needs. The goal of distance education is to provide access
to education that would otherwise not be available due to time barriers,
lack of faculty, and funding. Mississippi must make investments in a wide
range of technology delivery systems to ensure student access, to take advantage
of the rapid growth in technology, and to deliver education cost effectively.
Distance education should also provide programs for Mississippi students
with special needs, whether for advanced programs or for special education.
Distance education should be available for individuals or classes.
The appropriateness of a particular technology should be determined by a
number of factors:
- the curriculum
- the number of students to be served
- the location of students
- the time of day and school schedules.
Among the more widely used types of distance learning approaches are satellite
transmission; broadcasting; fiber-optic and copper networks; and other wireless
communications, including Instructional Television Fixed Service (ITFS),
personal communications devices, wireless local-area networks (LANs), and
wide-area networks (WANs).
In the educational setting, the mediums presently in wide use for distance
learning include the following:
Broadcasting
This involves one-way transmission of video and audio. Programming broadcast
over Public Broadcasting Services and public television stations to educate
and inform viewers, instructional programming designed for use in the classroom,
and staff development programs for teachers and administrators are examples
of this type of distance learning, which has been available for over twenty-five
years. A recent study conducted by CELT to determine the technologies being
used in public schools in Mississippi found that 92% of teachers are comfortable
using television as a learning tool.
Videotape Distribution
Videotapes are sometimes used for course delivery and can be a cost-effective
method for delivering course content. Videotapes provide a way to reach
students who do not have access to other delivery systems or face scheduling
barriers. It is currently used in alternative schools and for delivery of
undergraduate and graduate credit.
Satellite Delivery
This involves one-way video, two-way audio, and sometimes two-way data transmission.
Credit courses for middle school through post-secondary and graduate level,
as well as professional development programs for preservice and inservice
teachers, are offered through this format. Satellite-delivered programs
in science, mathematics, and language arts are also available on the elementary
level. This delivery method is interactive in that the learner may interact
with the teacher by telephone through an audio bridge, by fax, or through
a computer network. VSAT (Very Small Aperture Terminal) technology is growing
also in its use for data transmission.
Interactive Compressed Video Systems
These systems deliver interactive two-way video and audio and sometimes
data to students and teachers. Full motion video provides a signal akin
to open broadcast television. Compressed video offers picture quality similar
to that of VHS videotape. Compressed video can be provided via fiber optics,
copper land lines or microwave. Advantages include the ability to receive
or originate from any site and the two way audio/video interactivity which
other systems lack. The disadvantage, at present, is the relatively high
cost of interconnectivity resulting in a high per-user cost.
Computer Networks
This involves using computers, LANS, WANS, and on-line services, including
the Internet. Because computer networks are rapidly increasing in availability
and complexity, a variety of educational purposes and populations are turning
to this delivery method as cost decreases and course availability increases.
Desktop video and video-conferencing utilizing computer hardware accessories
is employed widely in corporate business, but has not seen as yet widespread
use in K-12 education. Desktop video offers a low-cost method of interactive
video conferencing, but at present does not meet the demands of full classroom
distance learning. While the CELT study showed that less than 10% of Mississippi's
public schools are wired currently for computers, on-line delivery will
become an important application in distance education in the future.
ITFS
Instructional television fixed service (ITFS) utilizes microwave technology
and is frequently called "wireless cable." The state's system
is currently under construction. ITFS delivers both original broadcast of
programming and rebroadcast of programming from other sources.
Wireless Communications
This includes direct-broadcast satellite, broadband broadcast radio, personal
communication (hand-held radios and cellular phones), wireless local area
networks, and advanced television. It is expected that wireless technology
will greatly facilitate delivering the National Information Infrastructure
to schools and other learning sites, particularly rural and inner-city areas,
lacking wired communications.
Wide-Area Networks
Wide-area networks (WANs) complement the local-area networks by expanding
their reach. WANs link schools to schools and schools to educational providers
(colleges, universities, community and junior colleges, libraries, and public
broadcasting). Internet service is provided via WAN. Dedicated compressed
video and multimedia can also be delivered via WAN. The statewide education
technology network is based upon the WAN concept.
4.5.2 Existing Systems
Many states are developing and implementing expanded telecommunications
capabilities to benefit not only the elementary and secondary schools, but
also higher education, community improvement centers, public libraries,
medical facilities, and state government. State initiatives that may be
considered applicable to Mississippi include the following:
- South Carolina
Statewide broadcast television and ITFS networks provide all schools access
to student instruction and staff development programming. SCETV's digital
satellite system provides capacity for 32 audio/video channels delivered
to schools and other sites statewide to supplement existing services. The
South Carolina General Assembly funded the installation of satellite systems
for all public schools.
- Iowa
Taking advantage of a public/private partnership, Iowa Communications Network,
in three phases of work, reaches at least one end site in each of the state's
ninety-nine counties, plus the three major universities and Iowa Public
Television. This statewide fiber-optic network will expand to over 600 educational
end points within ten years. The state built the fiber-optic "backbone,"
with the private sector providing the "last mile" interconnection.
The system transports interactive, two-way audio, full-motion video, and
data, including low-cost access to the Internet.
- South Dakota
The Rural Development Telecommunications Network utilizes T1 interconnect
technology to provide 20 school, university, hospital and vocational technical
school sites with compressed video facilities. Another fifty sites in the
state have satellite receivers for reception of instructional programming,
using audio return for interactivity.
- Nebraska
Nebraska ETV operates a statewide public television network, wire-line cable
service to Omaha and Lincoln,and a digital satellite system (upgraded from
an analog microwave system) to provide a wide variety of programming resources.
They also operate Neb*Sat, a four-channel satellite network using satellite
downlinks at schools, cooperative extension offices, corporate and government
offices, and fiber optics to connect ETV with the Neb*Sat uplinks at major
universities, the Nebraska Department of Education, and the state capitol.
Compressed video transmitter/receivers are located on college campuses,
and ITFS transmitters serve selected communities. The satellite delivery
system serves as the home base for the national Ag*Sat network that is focusing
on agricultural needs.
- Utah
The Utah Education Network's EdNet provides interactive audio and video
to elementary, secondary, and highereducation institutions statewide through
microwave, ITFS, and fiber-optic technologies. "Hub" sites are
connected by fiber optics with standard telephone lines connecting them
with sixty-five school sites, delivering sixty-one different courses. The
fiber-optic lines provide capacity for simultaneous delivery of multiple,
full-motion video signals between the hub sites only.
Distance Learning in Mississippi
Some current distance learning initiatives within the state include:
- Distance learning in Mississippi consists basically of broadcast instruction,
satellite services, and compressed video systems. Some limited use of computer
networking exists, and a statewide ITFS system is under development.
Satellite Services
- The University of Mississippi, Mississippi State University, and Mississippi
ETV all have "uplink" transmit capability to receive sites; there
are approximately 275 schools with satellite receive capability. The Mississippi
Department of Education and ETV are partners in the Satellite Educational
Resources Consortium (SERC), which provides interactive video learning to
students and teachers across Mississippi and the country; ETV and Mississippi
State University both produce staff development programs distributed by
SERC; the University of Mississippi's Project LEAP offers a variety of courses
focused on literacy.
Community College Network (CCN)
- This interactive compressed video network is located at 15 sites across
the state, mostly on community college campuses. Priorities are given to
rural health, community college credit courses and workforce activities.
Fibernet 2000
- Fibernet links 15 high schools with ETV, the Mississippi University
for Women, and Mississippi State University for interactive video instruction
using compressed video. Originally offered via DS3 interconnectivity, it
is now on a T1 platform. Sites at the Mississippi Department of Education,
NASA-Stennis Space Center and the UM Medical Center will be added soon.
Internet delivery capability will also be offered.
Interactive Video Network
- IVN is operated by the University of Southern Mississippi. It links
four sites in southern Mississippi and the UM Medical Center in Jackson;
IVN provides pre-service and inservice training for educators, as well as
teleconferencing capability.
EdNet
- This is a 5-channel wireless cable service that is technically described
as ITFS (Instructional Television Fixed Service). EdNet is under development,
with transmit cells in Jackson and the Delta now operational. EdNet is a
consortium which includes ETV, SBCJC, IHL, and MDE. It is mandated to offer
ITFS service to all Mississippi schools by 1998. It is a full-motion video
service.
ETV
- Mississippi ETV offers K-12 instructional television services to virtually
the entire state by way of "open air" broadcasting. ETV also provides
college credit courses for distance learners, as well as video-conferencing.
4.5.3 Design Principles
In its report Education and Instruction Through Telecommunications: Distance
Learning for All Learners, the Council for Chief State School Officers (CCSSO)
cited five issues they deem critical to any distance learning plan:
- access to learning technologies
- training and outreach
- public/private partnerships
- statewide/multi-state applications
- positive federal actions (planning support, funding support, and favorable
regulatory climate).
We would add to this the necessity of:
- interoperability--building bridges between existing systems
- inter-agency collaboration/cooperation in areas of mutual interest
- matching the need to the system; no single form of distance learning
will meet all needs
- coordination by a local user group, wide area user group, and an advisory
committee
- sustainability--long-range planning to ensure development and maintenance
of systems is essential.
Barriers to Distance Learning
Several barriers to distance learning and recommendations for overcoming
them were cited in the previously mentioned CCSSO report. A unified approach
recognizing the importance of these findings is essential in Mississippi.
A brief summary of the findings and recommendations follow:
- Incompatibility of current technical systems--The recommendation of
the CCSSO is that entities involved must support and develop systems and
networks that are compatible, and those institutions planning to use distance
learning take special action to create organizational environments to achieve
compatible integration of technologies.
- Insufficient use of available resources--These reasons were cited
by CCSSO: the lack of access to all delivery systems everywhere; incompatibilities
that inhibit integration of distance learning resources; scheduling difficulties;
and the rigidity of the school day and year. It was recommended that systems
be developed that are compatible, but also interoperable; that private partnerships
be promoted; and that federal and state agencies, in cooperation with the
private sector, develop new resources for investment and capital developments
for distance learning.
- Costs of technology--Distance Learning involves both significant start-up
costs and continuing programming and operational costs. The recommendations
are:
- develop new resources for investments.
- coordinate support from federal agencies to provide efficient and effective
funding uses
- organize planning on the part of would-be users
- examine regulatory barriers
- resolve issues such as educational fee structures with telephone and cable
companies
- resolve copyright issues and viewing restrictions to ensure affordable
rates for educational uses\
-ensure availability of services to all levels of learners and maintain
reasonable fair use laws by working with regulatory agencies.
Training people to use distance learning technologies--The report cites
a study conducted by the U.S. Congress's Office of Technology Assessment
that reported 64% of teachers involved in teleteaching had not received
any prior training. The recommendation calls for professional development
programs for educators and administrators to include technical training
for the use of distance learning in formal education, and for distance learning
providers and users to join forces to strengthen distance learning content
requirements and formats.
- Course accreditation--This issue is most critical at the high school
level where state-regulated graduation requirements must be fulfilled. The
CCSSO recommends state educational agencies improve course accreditation
procedures to advance the use of distance learning and other alternative
offerings.
- Cost and accounting systems--It is difficult for school-based decision
makers to estimate or track the cost-effectiveness of using distance learning
technologies including space and personnel costs. Again, the CCSSO recommends
that providers of distance learning develop cost-accounting standards.
- Institutional structures--The local character of education in this
country complicates the use distance learning, as in the case of teacher
certification, for example. Also the organizational structure of both educational
institutions and businesses often prohibits effective planning for nontraditional
methods of instruction. This can be overcome by ensuring equitable access
to distance learning resources, promoting public/private partnerships, improving
course accreditation procedures, and taking special actions to create organizational
environments that will achieve desired effects.
- Programming quality--Different skills are needed for teaching on television,
and many formats tend to be "talking head" approaches. This can
be overcome through professional development programs, improved course accreditation
standards, and strengthening content requirements and instructional formats.
- Awareness and acceptance--Distance learning is still plagued by the
myth that it offers a second-rate alternative to real instruction in a classroom.
Again, strengthening course content and instructional formats is recommended.
The CCSSO also recommends the local, state, and national authorities undertake
awareness outreach activities to inform educators and the public of the
value and importance of distance learning.
4.5.4 Benefit Analysis
The educational and cost effectiveness of distance learning technologies
are determined by a number of factors:
- The needs of the district and the larger community as determined through
the local planning process
- Costs of program acquisitions such as program license/faculty costs
and per pupil cost
- Initial equipment or technology acquisition including costs of technology
migration
- Continuing costs such as telecommunications costs and personnel
- Appropriateness of technology to school district needs
- Ability to share expertise and curriculum within the state or district
- Educational appropriateness of the curriculum to the technology
- Ability to serve rural areas with low student populations
- Ability to provide special education students with educational programs
that districts cannot otherwise afford.
The benefits to be derived from distance learning must be carefully examined
with regard to equipment and operational costs. The following section provides
an analysis of distance learning systems.
Satellite Receive Sites
A receive-only satellite system can be used to receive instructional programming
from many state educational entities through the ETV, Mississippi State
University, and University of Mississippi uplinks. Programming from providers
such as PBS, SERC can also be received.
Benefits
One-time equipment and installation cost
Reception of programming from many providers
Adaptable to multiple technologies
Reception of multiple channels
Disadvantages
Less flexible schedule
Potential for service interruption due to adverse weather
Interactive audio only
Satellite Delivery Services
Currently ETV, MSU and UM must pay for satellite service on an hourly rate.
This makes scheduling contingent on satellite transponder availability.
If the state leased a transponder it would be available full time for use
by those state entities having uplink capabilities. Many states have opted
for this delivery system as a cost-effective means of broadcasting multiple
channels of instruction over their state or the nation. Interactivity is
handled via telephone where students may ask questions of the instructor.
Benefits
Low cost per school served/low one-time equipment costs
No increase in delivery costs as users increase
Interactivity through conventional telephone or fax
Multiple channels
Multiple uplink sites available
Disadvantages
Same as satellite receive sites
Interactive Compressed Video
Fibernet, CCN, and other interactive video networks are now in operation
in the state. These networks allow students and teachers full interactivity
via T1 circuits provided by a telecommunications carrier.
Benefits
Full interactivity between student and teacher
Computer file exchange
Graphics capability
Internet access provided through same pipeline
Disadvantages
High interconnectivity cost
High start-up cost
Limited audio and video quality
Complex network switching
Limited class size
Broadcast Television
ETV provides instructional television through a statewide network of eight
television stations. Nearly all schools in the state are equipped to receive
ETV programming, with some wired to make courses available in more than
one classroom.
Benefits
No continuing cost per school
Full motion broadcast quality video
Accessible to schools, libraries, and homes
No increase in transmission cost as users increase
Inexpensive receive system, readily available
Disadvantages
Limited air time availability
Limited interactivity (one-way passive)
Limited channel availability
On-line Computer Services
Multimedia computers are fast becoming essential learning tools in our schools.
Internet is the de facto standard for information exchange nationally and
internationally. It offers users with interconnected workstations access
to vast quantities of information. Users are also able to communicate with
data, voice, and limited video.
Benefits
Worldwide information access and communication
Universal communications standards
Excellent reference resource for K-12 students
Publishing capability
Limited interactive video capability
Available through conventional telephone dialup
Disadvantages
Limited network speed slows graphic intensive material
Rapid equipment obsolescence
Only 10% of schools wired for computers
Limited training available
Relatively high equipment cost per student
Relatively high maintenance and support cost
Software interoperability problems due to uncoordinated purchasing
ITFS (Instructional Television Fixed Service)
ITFS is a delivery system using wireless cable transmission as the pipeline.
EdNet, an ITFS network licensed to MDE, ETV, IHL, EdNet, and SBCJC, is now
accessible in two areas of the state. Special low-cost receive systems make
instructional programming available to schools and other educational institutions
and to home viewers. The commercial wireless cable partner will provide
1100 receivers free of charge (one per school).
Benefits
Low-cost receive equipment
Multiple channels
Interactivity through conventional telephone
Potential statewide coverage
Multiple educational entities can provide programming
Available to students at school and home
Disadvantages
Interactive via audio only
Limited programming availability
Reception limited by terrain
Dependence on private partner to provide facilities and equipment
4.5.5 Implementation of Distance Learning Plan
Mississippi has several distance learning capabilities. Fibernet 2000, the
Community College Network (CCN), USM's Interactive Video Network, LEAP and
SERC satellite projects, and EdNet are all valuable resources. While each
system may serve discrete needs, it is important that these services continue
to work toward full inter-operability. This will help maximize the "reach"
of distance learning resources in the state. Closer coordination in areas
of mutual interest will help Mississippi achieve the most effective use
of the limited resources it has available.
While major universities, ETV, and others may provide important "hubs"
for distance learning networks, the true effectiveness of any such statewide
initiative must be measured in the field at the end user sites. Unless there
is ready access to technology and the various distance learning networks
in even the smallest communities of our state, Mississippi will fall short
of the enormous potential that technology offers.
Accordingly, based upon benefit analyses developed elsewhere in this document,
it is imperative that Mississippi consider how to realistically empower
local schools and communities to be a part of the "information superhighway."
School districts must define their specific distance learning needs and
strategies and incorporate them into their local technology plan.
Focusing upon K-12 schools as a primary "end user" in this plan,
a three-step implementation plan is envisioned that would provide the following
minimum capabilities to each school upon completion.
The first stage of implementation would include (but not be limited to)
the following in each school:
- television set in each classroom
- videocassette recorder for each classroom
- camcorders (number based on school population)
- personal computer at each teacher station (minimum) with multimedia
capability, fax, modem, and printer
- telephone access in classrooms
- dialup access to Internet
- fax machine in each school building
- EdNet (ITFS) receive site
- PC to television set video converter
- master video distribution system for each school,
- The second stage for implementation would include (but not be limited
to) the following in each school:
- satellite receive system
- local-area computer network
- CD-ROM computer file server
- T1 Internet access (when required)
- Electronic media center,
The goal would be to include all of the above, plus:
- DS3 Internet/networking capability
- OC3 (155 Mbps) fiber-optic technology which is price competitive with
DS3
- desktop video-conferencing capability
- interactive video classroom for each county.
In striving to help ensure equity of access to the enormous learning resources
these technologies offer, Mississippi should complete initial capabilities
for every school within two years. Second stage goals would be implemented
by the year 2000.
The ideal distance learning system will exist when every school is equipped
with a satellite receiver and a master television system, and every classroom
is equipped with a television and VCR, enabling students and faculty to
access regular television broadcasts, plus programs and courses delivered
via EdNet, interactive compressed video, and satellite. In addition, a multimedia
computer should be provided in every K-12 classroom, with a ratio of one
computer for every five students.
The multimedia personal computer is the heart of the education technology
system for the school. With video, audio, and data processing capability,
it is adaptable to many teaching and information gathering tasks. Networking
these computers greatly increases the power of the system as it allows the
sharing of printers, CD-ROMs, scanners, and other peripheral devices and
also provides interconnectivity to the Internet for world wide information
sharing. It is therefore important to coordinate the building of both the
video and data infrastructure (cabling, systems etc.).
The power of this concept can be further amplified by interconnecting each
of the classroom computers with a television by using a VGA to TV converter.
This would allow all students to view text and graphics over a classroom
TV that are visible on the computer screen. Electronic field trips via the
Internet could be viewed by the entire class. CD-ROM information could also
be viewed in this manner. Further expansion of this concept could involve
the use of CD-ROM servers located in the classroom or school so that students
could share CD-ROM information, eliminating the need to purchase software
for every computer.
Learning-on-demand could be a valuable distance learning concept, as it
would provide any course to any student or classroom on demand. Unfortunately,
this concept requires very high bandwidths on networks. Also, the capacity
and speed of computers that store the courses as data are very expensive
due to the large fixed disk space required. CD-ROMs could also be used as
a form of learning on demand by providing access via a CD-ROM file server.
Technologists should monitor the progress of this technology so that at
the appropriate time it can be integrated into the distance learning environment.
Mississippi Distance Education Sites
Return to top of page